Best Peanut Butter Jelly in New York

Looking for the best peanut butter jelly in New York? We analyzed 7,926,091 Google reviews across 12,334 restaurants to find the top spots. Here are the best, ranked by verified review scores.

Best Peanut Butter Jelly in New York

↓ See full ranking below
Top Table
Top Table
2

Top Peanut Butter Jelly Spots in New York

Ranked by rating from verified Google reviews.

  1. 1Brooklyn Cupcake

    Brooklyn Cupcake

    Cupcake shop · New York · $$

    ★ 4.7714 reviews
  2. 2Leon's Bagels

    Leon's Bagels

    Bagel shop · New York

    ★ 4.31,274 reviews

Discover More in New York

More great dining in New York

Cuisine

Best Cupcake Spots in New York

Cuisine

Best Wedding Bakery Spots in New York

Dish

Best Banana Pudding in New York

Dish

Best Plain Bagel in New York

Dish

Best Dulce De Leche in New York

Dish

Best Pumpernickel Bagel in New York