Looking for the best peanut butter cookie in New York? We analyzed 7,926,091 Google reviews across 12,334 restaurants to find the top spots. Here are the best, ranked by verified review scores.
18 places in view
Ranked by rating from verified Google reviews.
HEADREST COFFEE
Coffee shop · New York
Levain Bakery
Bakery · New York · $$
Levain Bakery
Bakery · New York · $$
Levain Bakery
Bakery · New York · $$
Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop
Donut shop · New York · $
Schmackary's
Bakery · New York · $
Bird & Branch Coffee Roasters
Coffee shop · New York · $
B Cup Cafe & Eatery
Cafe · New York · $$
Merriweather Coffee + Kitchen
Coffee shop · New York · $$
Culture 307
Coffee shop · New York
maman
Coffee shop · New York · $$
La Colombe Coffee Workshop
Coffee shop · New York · $$
Insomnia Cookies
Dessert shop · New York · $$
Irving Farm Coffee
Coffee shop · New York · $$
Billy's Bakery
Bakery · New York · $$
Insomnia Cookies
Dessert shop · New York · $$
Seven Grams Caffe
Coffee shop · New York · $$
Think Coffee
Coffee shop · New York · $
More great dining in New York
Best Bakery Spots in New York
CuisineBest Donut Spots in New York
CuisineBest Wi-Fi Spots in New York
CuisineBest Corporate Gift Supplier Spots in New York
DishBest Banana Bread in New York
DishBest Blueberry Muffin in New York
DishBest Ice Cream Sandwich in New York
DishBest Oatmeal Raisin Cookie in New York
