Best Lemon Pie in New York

Looking for the best lemon pie in New York? We analyzed 7,926,091 Google reviews across 12,334 restaurants to find the top spots. Here are the best, ranked by verified review scores.

Best Lemon Pie in New York

↓ See full ranking below
Top Table
Top Table
6

Top Lemon Pie Spots in New York

Ranked by rating from verified Google reviews.

  1. 1Anita La Mamma del Gelato

    Anita La Mamma del Gelato

    Ice cream shop · New York · $

    ★ 4.71,881 reviews
  2. 2Gallagher’s Steakhouse NYC

    Gallagher’s Steakhouse NYC

    Steak house · New York · $$$$

    ★ 4.69,100 reviews
  3. 3La Bomboniera

    La Bomboniera

    Cafe · New York

    ★ 4.7489 reviews
  4. 4Old John's Luncheonette

    Old John's Luncheonette

    Diner · New York · $$

    ★ 4.31,503 reviews
  5. 5Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South

    Magnolia Bakery - Central Park South

    Bakery · New York · $$

    ★ 3.7519 reviews
  6. 6Zaro’s Family Bakery

    Zaro’s Family Bakery

    Bakery · New York · $$

    ★ 3513 reviews

Discover More in New York

More great dining in New York

Cuisine

Best Ice Cream Spots in New York

Dish

Best Banana Split in New York

Dish

Best Filet Mignon in New York

Dish

Best Mashed Potatoes in New York

Dish

Best French Onion Soup in New York