Best Butter Tarts in Toronto

Looking for the best butter tarts in Toronto? We analyzed 6,421 Google reviews across 16 restaurants to find the top spots. Here are the best, ranked by verified review scores.

Cassis Bake#1

Cassis Bake

Bakery · The Beaches

4.9145 reviews
Good Earth Coffeehouse - Yonge & Wellesley#2

Good Earth Coffeehouse - Yonge & Wellesley

Coffee shop · Church-Wellesley · $$

4.5660 reviews
Bread & Butter#3

Bread & Butter

Restaurant · Yonge & Eglinton · $

4.5501 reviews
Lazy Daisy's Cafe#4

Lazy Daisy's Cafe

Restaurant · Little India · $$

4.31,094 reviews
The Epicure Shop#5

The Epicure Shop

Gourmet grocery store · Cabbagetown · $$

4.6345 reviews

Best Butter Tarts in Toronto

↓ See full ranking below
Top TableTop Table
16

Top Butter Tarts Spots in Toronto

Ranked by rating from verified Google reviews.

  1. Cassis Bake

    1. Cassis Bake

    Bakery · The Beaches

    4.9

    145 reviews

  2. Good Earth Coffeehouse - Yonge & Wellesley

    2. Good Earth Coffeehouse - Yonge & Wellesley

    Coffee shop · Church-Wellesley · $$

    4.5

    660 reviews

  3. Bread & Butter

    3. Bread & Butter

    Restaurant · Yonge & Eglinton · $

    4.5

    501 reviews

  4. Lazy Daisy's Cafe

    4. Lazy Daisy's Cafe

    Restaurant · Little India · $$

    4.3

    1,094 reviews

  5. The Epicure Shop

    5. The Epicure Shop

    Gourmet grocery store · Cabbagetown · $$

    4.6

    345 reviews

  6. Craque [de] Créme

    6. Craque [de] Créme

    Dessert restaurant · St. Clair West

    4.4

    669 reviews

  7. Epi Bakehouse

    7. Epi Bakehouse

    Bakery · Leaside · $$

    4.5

    308 reviews

  8. Judy's Beach Café

    8. Judy's Beach Café

    Cafe · The Beaches

    4.9

    92 reviews

  9. The Greenwood

    9. The Greenwood

    Coffee shop · Little India

    4.6

    101 reviews

  10. Brick Street Bakery

    10. Brick Street Bakery

    Bakery · Distillery District · $$

    4.3

    470 reviews

  11. Now & Later

    11. Now & Later

    Bar · Koreatown

    4.3

    217 reviews

  12. La Bamboche Bakery

    12. La Bamboche Bakery

    Cafe · Riverside

    4.5

    72 reviews

  13. The Bread Essentials

    13. The Bread Essentials

    Bakery · Lakeshore / Mimico · $$

    4.7

    260 reviews

  14. Ma Maison

    14. Ma Maison

    Bakery · Islington Village · $$

    4.2

    386 reviews

  15. Hot Oven Bakery

    15. Hot Oven Bakery

    Bakery · Islington Village · $$

    4.2

    359 reviews

  16. Second Cup Café

    16. Second Cup Café

    Coffee shop · Willowdale · $$

    3.7

    742 reviews

Discover More in Toronto

More great dining in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Deli Restaurants in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Salad Restaurants in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Delivery Service Restaurants in Toronto

Cuisine

Best Cheese Restaurants in Toronto

Vibe

Best Coffee in Toronto

Vibe

Best Bright in Toronto

Vibe

Best Friendly Staff in Toronto

Vibe

Best Window Seating in Toronto

Dish

Best Sausage Rolls in Toronto

Dish

Best Sandwich in Toronto

Dish

Best Scones in Toronto

Dish

Best Challah in Toronto