Best Sicilian Restaurants in New York

Looking for the best sicilian restaurants in New York? We analyzed 28,241 Google reviews across 17 restaurants to find the top spots. Here are the best, ranked by verified review scores.

Best Sicilian Restaurants in New York

↓ See full ranking below
Top Table
Top Table
17

Top Sicilian Restaurants in New York

Ranked by rating from verified Google reviews.

  1. 1Sicily Osteria

    Sicily Osteria

    Sicilian restaurant · New York · $$

    ★ 4.62,981 reviews
  2. 2Osteria Barocca

    Osteria Barocca

    Italian restaurant · New York · $$

    ★ 4.62,787 reviews
  3. 3Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana

    Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana

    Italian restaurant · New York · $$

    ★ 4.62,471 reviews
  4. 4Piccola Cucina Uptown

    Piccola Cucina Uptown

    Italian restaurant · New York · $$

    ★ 4.62,275 reviews
  5. 5Norma

    Norma

    Italian restaurant · New York · $$

    ★ 4.61,678 reviews
  6. 6Norma Hell's Kitchen

    Norma Hell's Kitchen

    Sicilian restaurant · New York · $$

    ★ 4.61,197 reviews
  7. 7Concrete Sicilian Eatery

    Concrete Sicilian Eatery

    Sicilian restaurant · New York · $$$

    ★ 4.7578 reviews
  8. 8Bleecker Street Pizza

    Bleecker Street Pizza

    Pizza restaurant · New York · $

    ★ 4.56,225 reviews
  9. 9Il Melograno

    Il Melograno

    Italian restaurant · New York · $$

    ★ 4.6679 reviews
  10. 10Two Boots Pizza West Village

    Two Boots Pizza West Village

    Pizza restaurant · New York · $

    ★ 4.5708 reviews
  11. 11Norma Turtle Bay

    Norma Turtle Bay

    Italian restaurant · New York · $$

    ★ 4.8149 reviews
  12. 12Two Boots Pizza Upper East Side

    Two Boots Pizza Upper East Side

    Pizza restaurant · New York · $$

    ★ 4.6315 reviews
  13. 13Two Boots Pizza Upper West Side

    Two Boots Pizza Upper West Side

    Pizza restaurant · New York · $$

    ★ 4.6309 reviews
  14. 14Two Boots Pizza East Village

    Two Boots Pizza East Village

    Pizza restaurant · New York · $

    ★ 4.4971 reviews
  15. 15Little Italy Pizza

    Little Italy Pizza

    Pizza restaurant · New York · $

    ★ 4.24,252 reviews
  16. 16Pastai Restaurant

    Pastai Restaurant

    Sicilian restaurant · New York · $$

    ★ 4.3473 reviews
  17. 1783 1/2

    83 1/2

    Southern Italian restaurant · New York · $$

    ★ 4.3193 reviews

Discover More in New York

More great dining in New York

Dish

Best Salad in New York